In a stunning reversal of fortune, Allemagne‘s automotive powerhouses are finding themselves outpaced and outmaneuvered in the world’s largest car market. A recent Bloomberg report paints a sobering picture of how Volkswagen, BMW, and Mercedes-Benz are desperately scrambling to catch up with local Chinese brands in the electric vehicle race.
The EV Revolution Leaves German Brands in the Dust
The transition to electric vehicles has dramatically shifted the playing field in Chine, catching traditional automakers off guard. Once-dominant German brands are now struggling to compete with tech-savvy and affordable EVs from local manufacturers. Chinese consumers, particularly younger and more tech-oriented buyers, are increasingly favoring advanced features and software capabilities over traditional selling points like horsepower and handling.
A stark comparison between the BYD Dolphin and Volkswagen ID.3 illustrates this contrast. The BYD Dolphin offers a 420 km range, 10.1 inch screen, and 7.3 second acceleration, all for just 99,800 yuan ($13,700). In comparison, the Volkswagen ID.3 provides a 450 km range, 12.9 inch screen, and 7.6 second acceleration, but at a significantly higher price of 129,900 yuan ($17,800). This price and performance gap is representative of the broader challenges facing German automakers in the Chinese EV market.
A Dream Customer Turns Sour
The article highlights the experience of Ryan Xu, once a “dream customer” for German automakers. The Guangdong-based entrepreneur and her husband owned a Porsche 911 and a Mercedes-Benz G-Class, and were among the first buyers of the electric Porsche Taycan. However, their views on German cars have soured as Chinese EVs have improved.
Xu criticized the Taycan, which costs over $100,000, saying its software systems were “terrible” and that it was “just an electrified Porsche – and that’s it.” This sentiment echoes a broader shift in consumer preferences towards more technologically advanced and user-friendly vehicles.
German Automakers’ Desperate Catch-Up Efforts
Faced with plummeting sales and market share, German carmakers are now rushing to adapt. Volkswagen’s China chief, Ralf Brandstätter, raised alarm bells when he warned the supervisory board about Chinese competitors leaping ahead. In response, VW has taken several steps, including partnering with Chinese firms for autonomous driving and infotainment systems, investing in Guangzhou-based Xpeng to leverage their EV expertise, and even chartering flights to send hundreds of staff to the Shanghai auto show in April 2023 to see the competition firsthand.
Similarly, Mercedes has tapped CATL for batteries and Tencent for digital services, while BMW joined forces with Great Wall Motor to build EVs for its Mini brand. These moves underscore the urgency with which German automakers are trying to close the gap with their Chinese competitors.
The High Stakes Game in China
German automakers have invested heavily in China, operating over 40 factories – more than in their homeland. This massive footprint makes pulling out nearly impossible. As analyst Gregor Sebastian puts it, “Clinging to their position in China is ‘a huge gamble.’ They’re hoping they’re too big to fail.”
The German brands now face a difficult balancing act. They must adapt to Chinese preferences while maintaining their identity. This struggle is evident in Mercedes’ Sindelfingen plant near Stuttgart, where S-Class production – once a favorite of China’s nouveau riche – has been reduced to a single shift due to slumping demand.
Structural Challenges and Government Pressure
The article points out several structural challenges facing German automakers in China. Downsizing operations is difficult due to complex relationships with domestic partners and local authorities. The Chinese government is prioritizing domestic automakers, directing state-owned companies to focus on technology and market share over profitability. Furthermore, land in China is government-owned, making it nearly impossible to simply shutter and sell factories.
These factors put immense pressure on German carmakers to revive sales in an increasingly tilted playing field. The situation is further complicated by the Chinese government’s active efforts to build up its own manufacturers, creating an environment where foreign brands are at a distinct disadvantage.
The Software Gap
One of the most significant areas where German automakers have fallen behind is in software development. The article cites Volkswagen’s struggles with over-the-air updates for its first Chinese electric model launched in 2020. Owners had to send their cars to dealers for in-store upgrades, which could take days.
An IT engineer from Wuhan named Zhou shared his frustration with a Volkswagen ID.4 purchased in early 2022. He experienced screens going black while driving and regular glitches, a far cry from the expected German quality. Updates were often behind schedule or only available through dealers.
Zhou’s experience isn’t unique, and it’s driving customers away from German brands. He’s now seeking a replacement and says, “I won’t visit any German dealerships. I’ll only go for local brands, or Tesla.” This sentiment reflects a growing trend among Chinese consumers who are increasingly turning to domestic brands or Tesla for their EV needs.
EVXL’s Take
The struggle of German automakers in China’s EV market underscores the rapid evolution of the electric vehicle landscape. As we’ve seen in our coverage of BYD, Xpeng, and other Chinese EV makers, the focus on technology, affordability, and local market understanding is proving to be a winning formula. This shift not only impacts the Chinese market but also has global implications as these companies expand internationally.
The challenges faced by VW, BMW, and Mercedes-Benz serve as a wake-up call for traditional automakers worldwide. The EV revolution isn’t just about swapping out powertrains; it’s a fundamental shift in what consumers value in their vehicles. Software, connectivity, and user experience are now just as important – if not more so – than traditional automotive engineering prowess.
As we’ve reported in our Volkswagen coverage, the company’s struggles in China could have far-reaching consequences for its global EV strategy. The outcome of this high-stakes game in China could determine the future of these storied brands and reshape the global automotive landscape.
What’s your take on the German automakers’ challenges in China’s EV market? Do you think they can catch up, or is it too late? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Découvrez plus de EVXL.co
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.