Tesla vs. BYD in Canada: How Ottawa’s China EV Deal Hands Tesla a Head Start While Chinese Rivals Wait

Canada’s new China-EV tariff agreement lands just days after BYD officially dethroned Tesla as the world’s largest EV manufacturer, creating an unexpected lifeline for the American automaker in a market where it already has boots on the ground. The deal announced last Friday slashes import duties from a prohibitive 100% to just 6.1% for up to 49,000 Chinese-made vehicles annually, according to Reuters, and Tesla’s Shanghai factory is positioned to resume Canadian exports almost immediately while competitors like BYD face months of certification delays.

The Fact: Canada will allow 49,000 Chinese-made EVs annually at 6.1% tariff rates, with volumes potentially rising to 70,000 within five years, according to Prime Minister Mark Carney.

The Delta: Tesla equipped its Shanghai plant for Canadian exports back in 2023 and already shipped over 44,000 vehicles to Canada that year before 100% tariffs forced a halt. No other automaker has this infrastructure advantage.

The Buyer Impact: Canadian consumers may soon see Shanghai-built Model 3s return to dealerships, but affordable Chinese EVs priced under C$35,000 remain 8 weeks away from certification at the earliest.

Tesla’s Shanghai infrastructure provides an immediate competitive moat

Tesla’s position as the likely first beneficiary of Canada’s tariff reduction stems from infrastructure investments made three years ago that no competitor can replicate overnight. The company equipped its Shanghai Gigafactory in 2023 to build and export a Canada-specific version of its Modelo Y, Reuters reported, and the facility began shipping vehicles to Canada that same year, boosting Vancouver port imports by 460% year-over-year to 44,356 units.

When Ottawa imposed 100% tariffs in 2024, citing China’s state-directed overcapacity policy, Tesla was forced to pivot. The company switched to shipping Model Ys produced at its Berlin factory to Canadian customers, a more expensive route that squeezed margins. But the cheaper Modelo 3 sedan, which is mostly built in China, essentially disappeared from the Canadian market.

“This new agreement could allow resumption of those exports rather quickly,” said Sam Fiorani, vice president of research firm AutoForecast Solutions, in comments to Reuters.

Tesla’s existing Canadian retail network of 39 stores provides another advantage that Chinese rivals cannot match, Reuters noted. BYD e Nio have no sales presence in Canada, meaning they would need to build distribution infrastructure from scratch even after their vehicles receive certification.

Byd Recalls Nearly 97,000 Evs Over Potential Fire Risk
Photo credit: BYD

The quota structure favors affordable Chinese EVs that Tesla doesn’t make

Half of Canada’s 49,000-vehicle import quota is reserved for EVs priced under C$35,000 (approximately $25,189 USD), a segment where Tesla has no offerings. Bloomberg reported that this pricing requirement extends through 2030 to ensure lower-cost options reach Canadian consumers. Every Tesla model currently exceeds this price threshold, which means the company can only compete for the premium half of the import allowance.

“The beneficiaries are likely to be Chinese automakers and the Canadian customers looking for an entry-level vehicle,” Fiorani told Reuters.

Transport Canada will certify new Chinese EVs within just eight weeks under the agreement, according to a government official with knowledge of the deal who spoke to Bloomberg. This accelerated timeline could see BYD, which overtook Tesla in European sales throughout 2025, enter the Canadian market by spring. The company already operates an electric bus assembly plant in Ontario, Reuters reported, demonstrating some familiarity with Canadian regulatory requirements.

Geely-owned brands Volvo and Polestar stand to benefit alongside Tesla

Volvo e Polestar, both controlled by Chinese automaker Geely, join Tesla as immediate beneficiaries because they already hold North American vehicle certification. Both brands exported China-made cars to Canada before the 2024 tariffs shut down that trade route. Bloomberg Intelligence analysts including Joanna Chen identified these companies as the initial winners, since manufacturers without existing certification face the eight-week approval process before they can ship vehicles.

Geely-controlled sports car brand Lotus welcomed the agreement, Bloomberg reported. Its Eletre electric SUV currently starts at C$313,500 ($225,600 USD) in Canada, and the brand expects its selling price to drop by approximately 50% under the new tariff structure.

Polestar has been particularly hard hit by U.S. and Canadian tariffs, according to Bloomberg, prompting the company to pivot its focus to the Polestar 3, which is manufactured at its South Carolina factory, and the Polestar 4, produced through a contract manufacturing deal with a Geely-Renault joint venture in South Korea.

“Tesla indeed has an advantage with its offering of a few models, versions and simple production lines so that it can be flexible to sell cars produced in any country in any markets to achieve the best cost efficiency,” said Yale Zhang, managing director at Shanghai-based consultancy AutoForesight, in comments to Reuters.

Canada’s divergence from U.S. trade policy creates North American tension

Canada’s tariff reduction directly contradicts American trade policy, where the Biden administration quadrupled tariffs on Chinese EVs to 100% in 2024 and the Trump administration has maintained those barriers. Trump officials have already criticized Canada’s decision, Reuters reported, viewing it as undermining unified North American resistance to Chinese automotive exports.

The deal represents part of a broader trade agreement where Beijing will reduce combined tariffs on Canadian canola seed from approximately 85% to 15% by March 1, 2026. This agricultural concession unlocked nearly $3 billion in export orders for Canadian farmers, as we detailed in our coverage of the Carney-Xi agreement last week.

Bloomberg noted that the Canada deal adds to a buoyant month for the Chinese auto industry after the European Commission also paved the way for manufacturers to avoid its most punitive tariffs. These moves underscore growing divergence with President Donald Trump’s increasingly disruptive trade policies and have the potential to reshape the North American auto industry should Chinese firms establish a firm foothold in Canada.

John Zeng, head of market forecast for China at London-based consultancy GlobalData, told Reuters that the quota offers Chinese carmakers an opportunity to test the waters in Canada, where there is a large population of Chinese Canadians. CBC reported that Canada wants to explore joint ventures and investments with Chinese companies within three years to build a Canadian electric vehicle using Chinese manufacturing knowledge.

EVXL’s Take

This story perfectly illustrates how Tesla’s global manufacturing strategy, which we’ve tracked through the 9 millionth vehicle milestone at Shanghai and the 5 million battery pack celebration, provides flexibility that competitors simply cannot match. When tariffs shut down one export route, Tesla pivoted to Berlin. Now that Canada has reopened the door to Chinese-made EVs, Tesla can pivot right back.

The irony is unmistakable. Tesla spent 2025 losing its global sales crown to BYD while watching Chinese competitors dominate European markets. Yet in Canada, Tesla’s early investment in Shanghai export infrastructure hands it a head start over those same rivals. The company’s 39 Canadian stores, established certification, and existing customer relationships mean it can resume Shanghai exports almost immediately while BYD builds distribution from scratch.

But the quota structure reveals Ottawa’s true intent. Reserving half the allocation for vehicles under C$35,000 signals that affordable Chinese EVs are coming to Canada, just not immediately. Tesla’s Canadian EV credit windfall demonstrated how the company dominates when policy favors it. This time, policy is designed to eventually diversify the market.

Expect Tesla to capture the lion’s share of the premium quota segment in 2026 while Chinese brands like BYD, once certified, begin competing for budget-conscious Canadian buyers starting in Q2. By 2027, when the quota potentially expands toward 70,000 vehicles, Tesla’s first-mover advantage will matter far less than its ability to compete on price and product freshness against manufacturers operating on 18-month development cycles.

Editorial Note: This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI to ensure technical accuracy and archive retrieval. All insights, industry analysis, and perspectives were provided exclusively by Haye Kesteloo and our other EVXL authors, editors, and Youtube partners to ensure the “Human-First” perspective our readers expect.


Saiba mais sobre o EVXL.co

Assine para receber nossas notícias mais recentes por e-mail.

Copyright © EVXL.co 2025. All rights reserved. The content, images, and intellectual property on this website are protected by copyright law. Reproduction or distribution of any material without prior written permission from EVXL.co is strictly prohibited. For permissions and inquiries, please Entre em contato conosco first. Also, be sure to check out EVXL's sister site, DroneXL.co, for all the latest news on drones and the drone industry.

FTC: EVXL.co is an Amazon Associate and uses affiliate links that can generate income from qualifying purchases. We do not sell, share, rent out, or spam your email.

Haye Kesteloo
Haye Kesteloo

Haye Kesteloo é editora-chefe e fundadora do EVXL.coonde ele cobre todas as notícias relacionadas a veículos elétricos, abrangendo marcas como Tesla, Ford, GM, BMW, Nissan e outras. Ele desempenha uma função semelhante no site de notícias sobre drones DroneXL.co. Haye pode ser contatado em haye @ evxl.co ou @hayekesteloo.

Artigos: 1736

Deixe uma resposta